Some Village Trustees 'Uncomfortable' in Reimbursing Projects for Firehouse Pizza and Pub
Restaurant owners have asked for funds for water main changes and for service to a retaining wall.
The Oswego Village Board will be voting at its next meeting on Tuesday, Feb. 5, on whether to provide reimbursement for two separate projects for the Firehouse Pizza and Pub, after much discussion at its last meeting.
The Village was approached by Firehouse Pizza and Pub, which opened in December in downtown Oswego, for reimbursement for waterline improvement, as well as replacement of a retaining wall at the village-owned building.
Police Chief Dwight Baird, who served as interim village administrator at the time Firehouse Pizza originally approached the village about occupying the space at 65 W. Washington St. in September 2011 spoke on the matter at the board's Jan. 22 meeting.
Want free local news in your inbox every morning? Sign up for our e-newsletter.
The first issue dealt with waterline required for the Firehouse. Code requires a 1.5-inch pipe and the building only had a 1-inch pipe.
Originally, the project was to have cost about $9,000 with the village paying half. Baird said the cost to change the pipes and additional work under village streets escalated to about $35,000 — about $18,000 of which the village would need to cover given the deal to cover half the bill.
Village staff suggested increasing the Village’s reimbursement to help cover the new costs.
President Brian LeClercq said in his mind the pipe fell under infrastructure upgrades, and trustee Jeff Lawson said it was the Village’s responsibility to upgrade water pipes and was not opposed to supporting it.
The second issue was the retaining wall that extends from 63 W. Washington to 65 W. Washington.
“The retaining wall was going to need to be replaced from day one,” said Baird.
He said according to the restaurant's owners, the wall sustained heavy rainfall damage last April and they were seeking reimbursement. Heavy machinery that was located atop the wall was also suggested as possibly damaging the wall.
“So they’re looking for is reimbursement on property that isn’t theirs,” clarified LeClercq.
The Village’s part of the 108-foot wall on the properties would total a little over $6,000 in repairs.
For more conversation and a slightly different take on the news, follow Oswego Patch on Facebook.
Trustee Gail Johnson said she rarely disagreed with staff recommendation, but felt uncomfortable putting out money to Firehouse. In September 2011 the board approved a loan of $130,000 for the restaurant’s owners from the village’s revolving loan fund at a rate of 3 percent over 10 years.
“We have a pattern of behavior regarding disrespectful treatment of village staff. They have had late payments, at least two that the made up with an (non-sufficient funds) check,” said Johnson, saying there also was a pattern of unresponsiveness and irresponsibility.
“I cannot justify putting another penny forward. I feel very uncomfortable putting out more money… I have no faith our loan is going to be repaid," Johnson said.
Trustee Terry Michels agreed, saying he was also uncomfortable with spending more money on the project. Michels has previously cited what he called the owners' poor business plan and working without building proper permits.
“They were doing their own thing and taking their time. This is a year and some months later now,” he said.
Trustee Tony Giles suggested the items be broken into two parts, approval for the waterline and approval for the retaining wall.
Both items will be voted upon at the upcoming February meeting.
TLC Carpet Floors and More, Inc.
7:19 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Lot of funds going into a building that was going to be torn down. Gotta sell a lot of Pizza to pay back all this money. Good luck Firehouse, wish you luck in 2013.
Jane Enviere
8:01 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Late payments, NSF checks...yeah, I can see this is going really well! I'd be preparing to write-off that genius of a loan.
Dianna Hunter
9:40 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Co-owner skipped out on Mason Square a few years back too. I hope the Village did credit checks, etc. before granting the loan.
ayar
10:19 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
How about we pay our share back "gradually" in the form of money off of each monthly loan payment ? they get their money back, and we get our monthly guaranteed until they paid off their loan.
Karin McCarthy-lange
2:20 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
I think this is a great suggestion and should be considered by the village board.
hunt club
4:25 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Agree, take the "excess" that the village agrees to and put it into an "escrow" that goes directly back to the village thereby allowing the tennant to effectively be mortgage free for a while.
John Public
10:48 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
The Village really needs to think about how to invest in the downtown development, and this is part of it. The Downtown area could and should be a major source of revenue and pride for the village, but instead it hosts both new and dying businesses alongside vacant lots and eyesores. Look at our neighboring cities for examples of what a downtown area should be. The Village needs to make encouraging the right kinds of businesses a priority.
scott baish
10:55 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Good call ayar! That way village gets payments on time and the business has a chance to grow and gain clientes to establish and great and successfull business which downtown is in desperate need of!!!
Mike Lowry
11:11 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
A full year of the loan has already been paid and the loan is current! Using common sense, they had to put up an extra 24k, that was part of there reserve, to do repairs and upgrades on property that is not theres or part of there leases property! Lets not forget the 300k in cash put in on top of the 130k loan! And the reality is, the property is worth 3 times the 130k now that Firehouse has renovated it. Seems to me the Village is sitting very safe! 130k at risk on a 400k renovation and they did not have to spend money tearing down the building and continuing to not collect property taxes on it. Oh and lets not forget the TAX revenue its bringing in!
hunt club
4:32 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Yes, I think everyone in the village would have to eat there about three times to pay it off in one year. That is over 17,000 pizzas (each pizza for a family of 4)! That would be over six miles long end to end!
Mike Lowry
11:15 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
By the way, there food is amazing! Lets not forget the positives! Hopefully we support this place and not forget this is a community which is suppose to support each other and support these local businesses that risk alot to help build our infrastructures!
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
11:28 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
All I can say to the Village of Oswego board members is you are all hypocrites, I've lived in this town for 14 years and my collective experience is village employees treat the tax payers like crap. I personally witnessed a village employee use foul language toward the owners of the pizza pub during the construction phase of development. As a municipal employee of 25 years of service if I had ever used that kind of language toward a resident, tax payer or business owner I would have been fired on the spot, yet our village seems to embrace this type of treatment.
As for now wanting to back out on our agreement to the pizza pub I say shame on you, you clowns represent me as a tax payer so stop all the BS and pay what you agreed to pay. You complain about two missed payments which are part of a repayment deal not unlike the deal you made to share the cost of water and sewer upgrades, guess what that makes you hypocrites! The leadership in this town is a joke, yes lets get rid of the pizza pub so we can get another thrift store or model train store in downtown as these are major tax revenue sources, right Mr Mayor? Sure sounds to me like a personal grudge against small business owners in Oswego.
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
11:29 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Here is an idea, how about the Village board members clean their own closets before chasing out another sales tax generating business from our poorly planned downtown. I have driven by the pizza pub on the weekends and that place is packed every Friday-Sunday so please don't try and tell me the Village of Oswego isn't raking in money! This business opened in the most difficult time of the year so maybe lets give them a chance to thrive and bring in people who are now spending their money in Aurora, Plainfield and Naperville. If this seems confusing I can come to the village meeting with crayons and construction paper to make it easier to understand.
Kevman10
11:53 am on Monday, January 28, 2013
Correct me if I'm wrong, but if we as individuals were to borrow money from a bank to purchase a home and then we were late on 2 payments and another with a NSF check - do you think the bank would be very open to lending us more money if we're already having issues paying the original? The estimate on the water pipes was $9k - pay the half based on that (I'm sorry but $35k is a long ways off from the original $9k). I'm not familiar what was negotiated on the retaining wall. Aren't these guys supposed to have successful restaurant operations elsewhere? That being the case, I don't know why there are so many issues with late payment, NSF, etc.
But, I DO AGREE that our village is inept at best when it comes to figuring out what to do downtown or anywhere else in this town for that reason. I see we just hired a new OEDC - wonder how long he's going to sit around accepting a paycheck for nothing before he's gone. We've had very valuable real estate in this town (notably all of Orchard Rd and Route 34) and we've not brought any real industry business here other than retail, restaurants and we loaded Orchard up with all banks that provide nothing to the city in means of revenues. Although it was totally unorganized when I visited there and took over an hour to get our pizza, I hope Firehouse Pizza does make it. But, I'd be leery of giving anyone more money if there are issues already...
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
12:26 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
@ Kevman a estimate is just that a estimate it means what we think it will cost. When you car is damaged and they give you an estimate that amount is NEVER what it ends up being. Ever hear of governmental estimates being exceeded by Millions yes MILLIONS of dollars? I have maybe we should ask the village how much the construction of the new village hall was compared to the estimate sold to the tax payers.
The money owed to the Firehouse Pub is based on an agreement it's not negotiable or is it another loan it's money already owed. If your sewer line broke and the village said get it fixed and we will pay half, then it came time to get paid and the village said oh wait never mind we are not paying because we are inept will you be ok with that? Last year the village mowed down my park way tree and replaced it in the worst time of the summer, guess what it died I bet they won't be replacing it even through these clowns planted it at the worst possible time. This Village does what it wants no matter what they agree to do.
Mike Lowry
12:34 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
@kev, who's asking for another loan? Your comment makes no sense! Do you own a business? Or do tou just sit back and collect a check and incur 0 risk?
Kevman10
1:13 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Mike, slow down and read the comment - it was an analogy. Your 2nd question and comment make no sense. Whether or not I own a business doesn't hold water in this article. Actually, I bust my hump in this town to get raped by taxes at every angle. And, I incur huge risk because I bought a house in this town and my property value keeps going down but my taxes continue to go up. Before you go spewing your non-sensical rants on me. Obviously, you and Jeff Paul have something to do with the Firehouse or a fondness of relation to it. I made an observation.
mike ellison
12:42 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
The details to this whole scenario seem a little bit confusing. If the village agreed to certain repairs then why didn't the village oversee those repairs themsevles rather than having the pizza business arrange for them, then getting reimbursed.
This is the problem you run into when government starts interferring with the free marketplace. The village should have just sold the building and/or made the necessary improvements to the building prior to the sale. Now, they're apparently in the real estate business and using taxpayer's money to compete with private businesses.
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
12:58 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
One question, if the village is leasing the build with an option to buy doesn't hat make them the landlord? if so they are responsible for the sewer and water lines. The Village shrugged off their responsibility to replace the warned down retaining wall it was an eye sore, lets be honest. All one needs to do is go look at that the portion of the wall that was replaced by the owners of the pub and then look at the section the village refused to fix it's disgusting and typical village BS. I agree with Mike why didn't the village fix or oversee the repair effort? Better yet why hasn't the village completed their section?, believe me if that wall was on my property the village would be sending over their condescending, disrespectful building inspectors mandating its repair (have you ever tried to build anything in this town, the inspector thinks he is the GOD of Oswego). Why the double standard?
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
1:02 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
* correction worn down :)
Walt Hines
1:12 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Hopefully both parties involved had something in writing and had their lawyer's look this over. Now a days hearsay means nothing just like the good old hand shake.
Since when did the village become a lending institution? I hope they gave every other small business the same opportunity, 3% pretty good rate.
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
1:17 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Lets hope so Walt maybe just maybe we can transform the downtown into something that attracts people instead of the eye sore it has become. The old alexander lumber deal the board crushed isn't looking so bad after all. I guess success depends on if the village board likes you or not (big box retailers vs small business owners).
Ina D. Know
1:47 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Jeff it was actually 20 years not 25 as a municipal employe before you found an easy way out. All you did was complain about how the Village was screwing you. Yet you wanted them to treat you like a king...Talk about hypocryte..
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
1:40 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
@ KevMan10 your assumption is incorrect I have nothing to do with the Pub I'm not fond of the Village pushing people around and like you I now own a house in this over taxed community that has lost over $200,000 in value firmly keeping me stuck in this GOD forsaken town so don't assume you know everything. I wish to see any business that can generate taxes and thereby lower my taxes succeed, DUH!
Jane Enviere
1:50 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
LOL on the Alexander comment! Because people would just be beating down the doors to live in condos in downtown Oswego. lol I mean, what with our hopping downtown and walkability, it's just perfect for the exurb resident looking for great shopping, cool restaurants and the chance to just stroll out their condo door to catch the train.
Oh, wait...
jane r
2:12 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
So far the reviews for them are pretty disappointing. Hours to wait for food..poor service and a general lack of organization. I strongly say NO to helping them out any further ..especially when the city..ie...us taxpayers, will be eating their original loan.
Pam L
4:49 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
@Jane - you have obviously never been to the pub....am I correct in saying this??? I've been in several times and always had great service and great food. Hours to wait? WAY exaggerated. Someone made a comment about the village being a landlord - I would have to say that's correct. I have rented in the past and when something breaks or isn't up to code the landlord fixes it. Especially with code violations (unless they are Slum-Lords). Talk about a lawsuit if its not fixed and someone gets hurt or sick. If the original agreement was for the village to pay half of the bill - then they should. Sheesh people. Can anyone say something positive? Like the business is bringing revenue into the city. They EMPLOYEE people & have IMPROVED downtown just a bit???? As for the late payments...well that happens to the best of us. They have a NEW business, which will take time to get their cash flow down pat. Who can sink $300 grand into a place then not have issues today? POSITIVE thoughts. Shame on you for your negativity.
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
2:51 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Ina D K now get your facts straight before posting slanderous statements under a false name or are you a coward. 25 totals years learn to count
Mike Lowry
4:27 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
@ Jane, bad reviews? I just went on to there facebook site and seems to me they already have over 1000 likes in only a few months open and i found maybe half a dozen to a dozen bad comments! 988 out of 1000. Thats pretty amazing if you ask me! Dont just point out the negatives, also recognize the positives!
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
5:25 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Ina D. Know= is a Downer Grove Fireman( not a very good one either) with a personal grudge against the owner of the PUB so his comments are biased... FYI
Mel
5:59 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Whose retaining wall?? Oh the village, let the landlord pay for it!
Who has not bounced a check??! Oh yeah 90% of people have, specially when people that owe you money don't pay!
The village cries that the restaurant bounced checks but they don't pay half (yes only half) of the wall that was put on the villages property! Is this insane?
Loans? Oh wait the loan that they got and put into the building that was about to be demo?
If it cost 130k for the village to do that without one hour of any of their members sweat I think they are getting away cheap. If you haven't noticed downtown Oswego is a ghost town.
As a resident I will say thank you tap house and firehouse pizza for trying to give our downtown a little life!
@jane you obviously are just yapping on FB, I have been in and out of there in less than hr with a full belly.
What about their employees? Offering jobs to young Oswego residents?
I guess that doesn't count right?
if they close, the village gets back a BRAND new restaurant that they can sell or rent! Instead of having a dead building like 75% of our downtown.
You guys all claim to support local businesses but to me it doesn't seem like that, however I see this place packed to the rim every weekend with people from all around (aurora, Plano and Montgomery)
Like someone once said haters will always hate!
Don't worry owners and customers of firehouse pizza people like me have your back and will still go to eat your awesome pizza
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
7:15 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Well said MEL
Jane Enviere
8:11 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Wow - 90% of people have bounced a check? Glad to be a 10%er! lol
Oswego Resident
8:52 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Agreed Jane. I'm well into my fifties and have never bounced a check or gone back on a deal. How sad that a lot of people these days seem to think that those actions are the norm.
Walt Hines
8:10 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Either side could be at fault here and until we hear the story in detail we can all assume the worse. The back and forth between who owes what should be handled by the lawyers and the contract that was written up. I'm sure in this day and age a legal and binding agreement was set forth between the two. This should protect both sides and make this disagreement come to an end. May we all move forward in the New Year.
Jeff Paul CCRN RN
9:16 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Congratulations Jane I have never bounced a check either however I think if you conducted a servey a great majority of people probably have bounced a check that does not mean your a horrible person. Maybe if the village had paid their share ( in my opinion 100% after all they do own the property ) the funds would have been available. Just spit balling here but unless you have inside information it's possible you don't have the whole story.
Jane Enviere
9:40 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Bad day at the hospital, Jeff? lol I'll say this much -- I agree with about 1% of anything that Trustee Johnson ever says. And this makes up about all of that 1%. I give this place less than a year. It's a lousy location (I'd say that about just about anywhere downtown -- most people have no desire to be down there. For a variety of reasons.), and if you are already missing payments and passing rubber checks, it's safe to say there is a problem. That isn't a moral judgment. It's basic finance.
People can say what they want about the evil big box stores and the devil's corridor over there on 34 filled with all the small business killers (lol), but the reality is that those types of businesses are what the majority of area residents want and where they are spending their dollars. Personally, I don't care what happens to this pizza joint. We tried it, were unimpressed and have moved on. If others love it - great for them. Win, lose or draw -- the pizza place isn't going to do anything for my tax bill so I'm not about to lose sleep over them. I do hope that the Village works to make a sound decision on this issue because they don't seem like a good bet.
Kevman10
10:05 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Jeff, I've followed your posts all day and all of them have been very angry and targeted. You claim to have no grudges, information or ties to the situation but attack everybody at every point when the Firehouse Pizza Pub is mentioned. Maybe you have some inside information you'd like to share with everybody? Just spit balling here... I truly do hope that the joint makes it, seriously. But, step down off the soap box. Maybe I'm wrong here - but as mentioned in my first post - I thought these guys have multiple pizza joints that are flourishing? And, again, if that is the case - no matter the pipe or retaining wall repairs; shouldn't their successful business ventures elsewhere be able to cover the nsf's? Don't lose your mind, Jeff - just asking a question. I figured you may be able to help with that since you have all the information. Thank you in advance...
Barbara
10:20 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
The village should have torn the place down when they took bids for demolition a couple of years ago - approximately $17,000, and this would not be a problem now.
Oswego mom 2011
10:42 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
Just an idea. Put the pizza place in the village taj ma hal. Plenty of space for ovens Plenty of parking. Install some pizza ovens and put up a neon sign above the village hall clock. FRESH pizza. Kinda like Krispy Kreme did. And that worked out really well for them. Right? Throwing some ideas out there.
Jane Enviere
10:53 pm on Monday, January 28, 2013
LMAO!! That might be the best idea yet. ; )
Oswego Resident
8:16 am on Tuesday, January 29, 2013
And it would make the place smell great!
Pat Stiles
10:36 am on Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Went on first Friday, there was mass confusion. But there were huge crowds also. Pizza took over an hour and was wrong. I don't think they expected the huge turnout, lesson learned. I have been back many other times with no problems. It's a NewYork style pizza which is different, but very good. I don't know or care what deals were cut, or voodoo economics were involved. When I go to a store or eat out I don't care what the spread sheet says,nor do I care. People want business in Oswego and when they come they can't wait to bust balls. If I go and the doors are locked then it wasn't meant to be. But as for now I enjoy the pizza. In fact I will be there again today for lunch at noon.
singlemom
11:07 am on Tuesday, January 29, 2013
How about the fact that the owners only pay one dollar a month in rent to the Village of Oswego....The owners are getting a great deal and the Village is screwing the tax payers....Really!!
Walt Hines
7:45 pm on Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Singlemom kindly explain this one. How can they only be paying one dollar a month in rent? I'm still trying to figure out when the village became a lending institution.