patching...
Update: Are you following us on Facebook? Like us at http://facebook.com/oswegoILpatch
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Kendall County Property Tax Revolt - A New Beginning

A big thank you to over 300 taxpayers who came out to the Property Tax Revolt Day gathering! Judie & Don Burks and I were not sure what to expect but the crowd was overwhelming! Thank you all! We enjoyed the frank discussions with everyone and heard too many stories of people who were leaving the area unable to pay the ever-increasing property tax bill. There were many older taxpayers living on fixed incomes but there were plenty of younger taxpayers who were actually looking at their tax bills. There was plenty of pain to go around.

Most asked what they could do. First step is to prepare for your appeal now. Don’t wait for the assessment to come in the mail. You have nice weather and plenty of time to find comparable properties or hire an appraiser. From what I heard time and time again yesterday was, “Don’t stop with the Board of Review. Take it to PTAB/the State.” Many, many times people were refused by the BOR only to win at the state level. The government doesn’t make it easy for you and they never will. Many people told us of states like Washington, Florida, Missouri, and Arizona whose property taxes for a $200,000-$300,000 home would be less than $2,000. Some as low as $1,000 for the same home in Kendall County whose taxes are $5,000-$12,000. Too many people think we can’t lower the taxes but look at just a few states who have found a way. Their schools, counties, and cities are flourishing with foreclosures galore. The question we need to ask is how come they can but we can’t?

The next step for our group is to organize and begin the research and rallies. They haven’t seen the end of us – only the beginning. I am setting up the email list right now and am asking any others who would like to be kept informed and/or to join the group to send me an email at: kendallcounty@gmail.com. If you have any expertise at all, we welcome it. Watch your email for an announcement soon. The subject line will be “tax protest.” I will attach the flyers and handouts from yesterday to everyone. Many wanted copies of the information.

We are a very diverse group from all over the county whose needs vary greatly due to school referendums, park districts, bonds, and much more but we are all in the same boat. We must put each group together to fight the battles in their own backyards. We are fighting different battles but we are all in the same war to be taxed fairly and cut the unnecessary spending. The war has just begun to hold people accountable, lower our tax bill, so we can all stay in our homes. Join us and help to find solutions.

Two links to stories on Patch and the Beacon-News:

http://beaconnews.suntimes.com/12866867-417/hundreds-join-kendall-tax-protest.html

http://yorkville.patch.com/articles/kendall-county-property-tax-revolt-focuses-on-education

Monita Gruhlke

4:03 pm on Sunday, June 3, 2012

Which public services do you propose that we cut?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Greg O'Neil

7:12 am on Monday, June 4, 2012

All of them, little waste in schools you say, baloney, lets start with the six million dollar swimming pool, the six million dollar sod farm on Grove Road, the 235,000 superintendent, etc etc etc. i spend over 400.00 per year to send school supplies with my kids. Teachers are not required to provide these things. We even are asked to send tissue paper. Don't target the schools? They are taxing us out of our homes, maybe we should ask MUCH less from the schools, like the taxpayer only paying for basic reading, math and other core courses. This is all we can afford. There are many ways to educate kids using technology, one teacher could teach hundreds of students. Think your IEA union will go along with that?

Mark A Johnson

4:35 pm on Sunday, June 3, 2012

Let's begin with waste in schools, cities, county, etc. As this group does research and holds discussions I'm certain we will find enough to go around. Good question. No answers yet. Haven't had our first meeting.

Reply

Monita Gruhlke

4:45 pm on Sunday, June 3, 2012

I work in schools, and find little waste. Teachers spend a lot of their own money on class materials and spend long hours at home preparing. They more than earn their salaries. Please don't target the schools.

Reply

Mark A Johnson

5:41 pm on Sunday, June 3, 2012

@Monita, 60%-70% of our property taxes go to schools so we could eliminate all funding for roads, sewers, police, firemen, and everything(total budgets) that goes to cities, county, and townships and not even touch the single biggest cost to taxpayers - schools. You don't want schools to be touched but here are examples of money that really didn't have to be spent: Nearly $1M for upgraded football stadiums, administrators pension bumps costing millions of dollars over the next 10 years, and much more. I know our group will have many battles over what to cut and what is sacred to each of them. The group will need to work through those issues no differently than the boards and councils do. The big difference will be we will be looking at cutting where they only look at reallocating the guaranteed increases they get every year. So my challenge is for you and any others who want to learn where the money goes and where the cuts can be made is to join the group and have your say. I know this group will make tough, wise decisions and make the local elected officials know the results. Please come and join us.

Reply

cindy

9:09 am on Monday, June 4, 2012

@Monita, you have a very one-sided approach. Please understand that the people who are fed up with ever increasing taxes are not mean-spirited people who "hate teachers." It is all too easy to belittle the opposition. The simple truth is that people simply do not have the money to pay for all the extra projects as Greg O'Neil included in his earlier response. When the economy is good, most of us are happy to pay a little more for extra projects but when we don't even have jobs and we're trying to figure out how we can buy food within our budget, it is making us literally sick to be asked to pay anymore. There are real tears shed when you come to the realization that you may have to foreclose on your home when you've been a responsible person all of your life. All the while, the teachers union refuses to allow the schools to let go of even the worst teachers, while insisting on high pensions and increasing salaries. Also, please tell me how you can educate a child in Florida for $1000 per child but it costs $6,000 in Oswego? There are no shortages of good teachers in Florida.

Reply

Dock Ellis

11:21 am on Monday, June 4, 2012

This is a question of markets - nothing more. Fewer homes are being sold and the prices are going down. Guess what? We still need services. And fewer people/homes are available to pay for those services, so the cost goes up for everyone. Is it fair? No, but life isn't fair folks. You can yell and shout your talking points and trash the teachers union all you want, but when your precious "tea party" school board is wasting money right and left - and violating the Open Meetings Act to boot - you have no ground to stand on. People would be more receptive to your message if you were more honest in your approach - that you are representing the right wing tea party people and nothing more!

Reply

Mark A Johnson

12:20 pm on Monday, June 4, 2012

@Dock Ellis, Actually, we had the area Tea Parties and the Occupy Wall Street folks want to join our day at the park and we told them no. We may have some similar beliefs as both groups but we are just ordinary people who are fed up. Demanding cuts will get their attention but maybe the answer is a whole new way of funding. We don't have the answers yet but maybe you do. Come and join us. Maybe you have some good ideas. If you only want to throw blame and innuendos around please join a different BLOG. As you are aware, there are plenty of others for you. Please join us if you are sincere because the majority of our group are sincere in wanting the insanity to stop.

Reply

mike ellison

11:50 am on Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Here's some areas where the District has wasted money in the past--- monogrammed carpet with the shool logo located in the entrance to OEHS- what is this, a corporate campus?, an indoor ELEVATED running track, a green room for video production, an auditorium that rivals those of private enterprise, practice sports fields so that the 'real' fields only get used on game days- you're paying for the 'real' fields to site empty 90% of the year, frivilous classes such as weaving......

These are just the quick ones I can think of off the top of my head.

Reply

John

12:10 pm on Sunday, July 8, 2012

While I definatly believe in paying my fair share to support the work of the schools, and government, the property tax in Will county is a cancer on the development of the area. My question, why do they need so much money from the citizens who will probably soon have to move to Indiana? Each and every expense needs scruitinized. That is how serious, in my opinion, this tax rate required to be collected for the cities / villages to balance there budget is. Hell, combined with my property tax, I pay close to 16% of my income then add the other 8-10% sales tax when I make purchases...what the hell are they doing with all that money? It is criminal. When/if housing improves, doubtful in IL as no one wants to pay 1k a month for property tax, then my ass is moving to Indiana.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tim

3:17 pm on Sunday, July 8, 2012

Can you hurry up and move then?

Having moved from IN, to IL, I can tell you that it is not nearly as nice as you seem to think it is.

Did someone force you to buy as large a house as you did? I pay nowhere near 1k/mo in property taxes. Not even half that, actually. Those that I know who do pay that much, easily have the income to pay for it. You don't have a tax problem, you have an income problem.

Carolyn Behrens

5:05 pm on Sunday, July 8, 2012

Looks like to me the elementary school my relative went to, did more art than anything else while the parents who are trying to make ends meet sit night after night helping their child with spelling, math and reading! Then comes the school pictures twice a year!! 45-60 $ each time. WHY twice, I'm. wondering. Then I love reading myself but a half hour a night even on the weekends. Then free tickets to Raging Waves, Great America and The Cougars games if you log so many hours of reading. So more reading!! These are just a few things that really bothers me about the elementary schools here in Yorkville. Oh and then the kids have to sell magazines to friends and relatives so the class can get Time weekly Readers! WOW!! What do you think? Am I just being picky?? Thanks for letting me vent!

hen school starts and one in the spring!! WHY!! Then donations to all kinds of

Reply

Danni

8:00 pm on Sunday, July 8, 2012

yep-everyone who is complaining has an income problem-not a tax problem - no retired teachers complaining?-no working teachers complaining?-secure non-fireable jobs or $100-$250 per year pensions-no income problem-no complaint and sweet-no income tax on that pension-my income tax-5%-yep-I surely do have an income problem

Reply

Greg O'Neil

9:10 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

Tim,
You are simply not paying your fair share of the tax burden then, if others are paying twice as much as you are then you are the beneficiary of free government services at the expense of others, a freeloader of sorts, right? You like that don't you. Why don't you follow your "wealthy" neighbors down to the gas station or to the grocery store and see if you can't get them to pay for half your bill, it's the same premise, they have more then they should pay more, right? This is exactly how local government works, its a socialist concept that steals from one to give to another. I think the tax assessor should double your taxes because you are using these services as much as anyone else, right? Why should someone subsidize your park and library but not your gas and groceries, thats not fair, but I'm betting given the chance, you would vote to have your neighbors pay for your food and gas, wouldn't you Tim. Now I know why they call you Hoosiers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tim

12:30 pm on Monday, July 9, 2012

I am paying exactly the same percent as everyone else.

Unfortunately, some people think that expensive house = status. They pay the same percentage as I do, yet complain that their taxes are too high. Their taxes are not too high, they just bought more house than they could afford. My taxes could go up 100% and it still wouldn't be a burden because I bought a house to stay warm and dry, not to show off as a status symbol.

Be honest, if you are paying 12K/yr in taxes, your house is still worth at least 300K AFTER the crash.

What you are actually saying, is that you want people who spent their money wisely to have their percentage paid in taxes increased, so that your taxes wont go up. Which is not surprising, because to you it is always someone elses fault/problem.

It is not my fault that you waste your money for the idea of 'status' in the form of housing. That was your choice. My choice, is to keep more of my money to do the things that I enjoy doing, and still keep a roof over my head, and stay dry in the rain.

Perceived status is more important to you.
Keeping my money is more important to me.

Life is not fair.

Jan Alexander

9:46 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

Note to All...This arguing and bickering will not provide a solution. Kendall County has a problem and we all need to look at the big picture. Some residents are doing well but TOO MANY are not. We need to respect our differences in opinion and be civil to one another. Join our group and maybe we can all find out what's really going on. We all want what is best for Kendall County. Come to our Rally this Friday. Together we can work to make a better Oswego for ALL it's residents.

Reply

russ harrison

10:13 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

Painful situations require painful actions.All change is painful,even change for the good.Obviously, the tax situation is painful to too many families.Changes to that situation will be painful as well.Private sector employees have been taking cuts to pay and benefits for several years.Many have been forced into retirement or unemployment to keep these businesses alive,and many businesses have died due to the economy.
So...what do we do?Continue to tax people out of their homes?Create a tax burden that discourages growth in our area?Here's a painful suggestion that may prevent more pain in the future:
Want a pay raise? You get to keep your job, there's the pay raise.Need more public employees?Show the current ones how to work more efficiently and eliminate the non productive ones.School payroll too high?10% cuts to the highest paid administrators and lowest qualified bidder gets the job.Still not enough savings?5% Paycuts for all...don't like it then go to another school district.Police needs more funds?Stop wasting money on expensive prosecution for minor pot busts and let the local police start fining violators like they've been asking to.Got sentenced to community service?Use their skills to enhance public services.Need a new building? Buy one on a short sale, there's plenty available.
It is time to stop putting bandaids on skin cancer and calling it a cure.Increased taxes will NOT cure inefficiency or waste,but will allow the continued erosion to our communities.

Reply
Comment_arrow

russ harrison

10:21 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

Before anyone gets on their high horse, I suggested pay cuts for all, true. But...paycuts for those above a certain income level is what I intended. Obviously the lowest paid workers that are struggling the hardest should not have their incomes reduced.

russ harrison

10:25 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

In the words of a well known political candidate: "Why don't you poor people just buy more money to pay your taxes and stop bothering us job creators?"
(insert politician's name...they all seem to be saying the same thing)

Reply

Jan Alexander

11:10 am on Monday, July 9, 2012

Well said Russ!!!! Will we see you at the Rally Friday?
Noon til 8:00PM @ Hudson Crossing.

Reply

Danni

12:16 pm on Monday, July 9, 2012

I am so curious-what did that retired ceramics teacher do that was so special for $160,000. pension he started collecting at 55 years old. I don't know if he had a Master's in Ceramics or if his students made the best clay flowerpots in the world-I don't understand why he gets 10 times more than me, I struggle and I have an MBA-plus my pittance doesn't begin until I am 67-by that time he has collected 2 million, or thereabouts and hasn't paid State Income Tax of $100,000. Is this a tax problem or and income problem, Tim and whose problem is it?

Reply

russ harrison

12:34 pm on Monday, July 9, 2012

A home rule county has certain options available to them during times of emergency. Once declared, actions that wcould seem to violate contracts and Union rights can be legally undertaken. In some situations, (and the rules are really vague about this, as well as the definition of what constitutes an "emergency or disaster") the actions can be left in force indefinitely, or until the state of emergency has been declared as resolved....with no obligations to fulfill agreements made PRIOR to the state of emergency being declared. There are several counties and municipalities in the US currently attempting to use this option after negotiations with Unions and employees for pay cuts and benefits reductions failed. The big question is: Does a severe economic downturn or a public majority (as defined as registered voters) declaration of "no faith" in local government qualify as as an emergency? If it does, then pay cuts and budget slashing may be legally allowable without recourse. If it does not, then the situation may deteriorate into one in which open revolution occurs...in which case we really will have a "state of emergency". Either way, the days of "How can we be out of money, we still have taxpayers checks!" are in dire need of coming to a close.

Reply
Comment_arrow

russ harrison

12:39 pm on Monday, July 9, 2012

and again, I want to make this clear, I am NOT demanding that the workers bear all the brunt here. I am saying that they may have to kiss any raises for now and in the future good-bye. Some non essential taxpayer funded projects will have to be eliminated or halted until we can reduce the budget to a workable number. By the way, for those not in the loop...The emperor's new clothes aren't really invisible... He's naked as a jaybird!

Danni

10:37 am on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Tim-you don't address either of my posts-my modest house was not a status purchase, rather a roof, an abode. That I am being forced from my home is due to being starved, squeezed and crushed by the insane real estate taxes and every other Illinois tax paying insane amounts and benefits to public employees, paying for medical care for 100's of thousands who are not citizens, and the micro interests on the funds I accumulated because I did not look to a future on the public dole. The words you use make me think you are on the public dole with plenty of income. Well, here is your future: the preyed upon do not have money machines, trees or printing presses. You probably have another 2-3 years before the music stops. Then your pomposity will subside-you too will be one of those who over-bought a house for "status." If you are not scared to death about your future, beyond just the local issues, you do not have even the barest smattering of knowledge about what is going on around you. Maybe you should read and listen more-maybe you should attend the July 13th rally.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Greg O'Neil

11:16 am on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Danni,

I think you just hit it out of the park where Tim is concerned. I was thinking he was a government worker as well, guess we'll never know the truth. I didn't build my house as a status symbol either and i sure as hell don't need to be subsidizing Tim's lifestyle either. The day of reckoning is near!!!

Comment_arrow

Tim

11:31 am on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Nope. not a public employee.

Im in my 30s, and will have my house paid off in 3 years. I even have enough saved that I could easily pay it off now, but I like the interest deduction.

Like I said, you bought a house for status. If you are being 'squeezed and starved' simply because your taxes have gone up a few percent, you bought more house than you could afford. A CURRENTLY valued house of 300K, 3500 sq/ft, within the Yorkville village limits(extra village taxes) pays less than the above quoted $1k/month in taxes. 30% less actually. It would take a house valued at ~500K to hit that 1K/mo. Not what anyone would call a 'modest house'.

You bought a house in an unsustainable exurb, relying almost exclusively on residential taxes for a tax base. And are now finding yourself squeezed with just a few percent uptick in taxes.

I would say it is directly a result of my previous 'reading and listening' that I find myself in the comfortable financial position I am in. Why would I want to listen to people at a tax rally who made poor short-term financial decisions, and are on track to make more similarly poor long-term decisions?

Perhaps it is you who needs to read and listen, maybe you would be able to better take responsibility for your own financial choices, instead of looking to blame someone else.

For the record, I completely support shifting school taxes onto the local level. It will give people an idea of what it REALLY costs to live in the area that they do.

Comment_arrow

Mark A Johnson

11:57 am on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

@ Tim - Just to bring you back to reality here, my son built his 2600 sq ft home($270,000) 3 yrs ago in the Yorkville city limits and last year his property taxes were almost $11,000 or just under $1,000/mo so the mega-home you keep talking about isn't really true here in Kendall County. I praise you for what you have accomplished but don't believe everyone can do that. Another son has a 5 yr old, 3000 sq ft home in the city and only pays $8,000 taxes. That unfairness is what I am trying to correct.

Comment_arrow

Tim

12:41 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

I notice you provided not a single shred of evidence to support that.

Here is a house, within the city limits, valued at 300K, and only paying 9K/yr.
http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/652-White-Oak-Way-Yorkville-IL-60560/4728391_zpid/
This 3K in taxes for every 100K in valuation, is almost identical to Will county, by the way.

How is your son paying 25% more, for a house that is worth 10% less? This particular house saw its taxes go up by 15% over 7 years, or just over 2%/yr. How horrible!

And yes, everyone CAN do it, they just chose not to. Nobody NEEDS 3000 sq/ft to live, they just WANT it.

These are yours and your sons personal choices. Just because they turned out to be poor choices, does not mean it is the fault of someone else, or it is somehow 'unfair'. And now you want those who were not greedy and lived within their means, to bail you out.

I just don't see what your complaint is, other than you don't want to pay taxes on the services and infrastructure your chosen community uses and needs.

Comment_arrow

Mark A Johnson

1:08 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

@ Tim, I guess you believe me to be a liar? I won't air my family business out here for someone who just wants to argue for the sake of arguing. I tried to be reasonable and give some facts but you just want to argue. Use your energy hijacking someone else's BLOG. The rest of us will discuss how to fix Kendall County's problems - You should go fix yours.

Comment_arrow

Tim

1:50 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

I did not say you were a liar, I said you provided zero evidence to support it. I know it is popular on patch for people to believe whatever they read, but I tend to make sure any information I base decisions on is verified by an external source. Especially financial ones.

If you did not want to 'air your family business', why did you bring it up in the first place? Backing away from what you brought up, when you don't like what it will show about your choices?

Instead of addressing the points given to you, about overbuying a house, you chose to brush it aside with a personal attack claiming I am arguing just to argue. Your failure to realize the entirety of your situation is exactly what landed you where you are right now, continuing in that pattern as you are now assures you will continue to find yourself in identical problems for the foreseeable future.

What changes have YOU made? You are quick to demand changes from others, but have not listed a single one you have made yourself. Again, it all boils down to you and your choices being pushed off as the responsibility of anyone but you.

Jillian Duchnowski

10:49 am on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

If you are interested in learning more about what the county is doing to promote economic development and diversifying the tax base, check out this article: http://patch.com/A-vSR2

Reply

Jane Enviere

1:30 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

I think there's merit in what a number of people are saying, on both sides of the issue. Bottomline for me, I live in a house that I might get $200K for (if lucky!) and my taxes are just about $8000. I know that I won't ever see a significant reduction in that amount. I get that. I get why. I just wish that the largest beneficiary of those checks I write would be more careful with their money. I know they need it, but it's how they spend it that bothers me. D308, I'm looking at you! ; )

Reply

Greg O'Neil

2:00 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Tim,
Many of us didn't move here from Hoosierville, we've lived here all our lives. Many are on fixed incomes, retired, or layed off and do not have additional resources to spend. It has nothing to with choices. I guess at 30 you just don't get it. At least have the guts to put your full name on the blog, we've had a number of fakers on the Patch and until you identify yourself, you can't and won't be taken seriously. For all we know you are not what or who you say, for that matter who cares what you think.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tim

2:09 pm on Tuesday, July 10, 2012

You are confusing the definition of 'few' with 'many'.

You can claim you have guts all day long.

Thank you for proving that this is all about status, greed, and ego, and not sound financial choices.

No amount of personal attacks you will make against me will change my financial situation. Do you think it will change yours?

Danni

8:59 am on Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Every blog has a "Tim". He is clearly clairvoyant as he has planned his present and future for total financial security and nothing will ever happen to him that he has not incorporated into his life plan. He will never be a victim of circumstance-he knows every circumstance he will encounter in his next 1-80 years, because he is clairvoyant; he knows exactly how much medical care he will need because he is clairvoyant; he knows exactly what his career path will be because he is clairvoyant; he knows which business to start, which employer to avoid, because he is clairvoyant; he knows exactly which investments will achieve his goal because he is clairvoyant; he knows I will not bother to address anything more he has to write on this post, because he is clairvoyant.

Reply

Danni

10:57 am on Thursday, July 12, 2012

Greg and Russ-I hope to meet you at at the Rally Friday-we are on the same page, the only plausible, reasonable, workable, inevitable and yearned for page.

Reply

Danni

11:40 am on Thursday, July 12, 2012

And let us not harbor any unrealistic impression of the "Tim" who tells us how he has it all together financially-his "like" for the "interest deduction", preferable to using his funds on hand to pay off his mortgage- here's where he reveals his true, and doubtful, money management skills that have gained him the wealth he claims at 30 years old, excluding an inheritance or marrying well: fact-there is no, none, nada , a less expensive, more financially beneficial way to pay for anything, other than cash. Perhaps one charges everything, but pays the entire bill each month-that's prudent-that's using an interest free loan, and only interest free loans are financially, good planning-do we think Tim has an interest free mortgage? I don't. I think Tim is living in a one-bedroom rented apartment, outside parking for his faded blue 1991 Jimmy, the persistant smells of pan fried perch and curry, the 3:00 AM crying babies, blasting boom boxes, fighting partners and slamming doors, the only "status" he can afford with his "income" problem. But, if he were to have a greenback curriculum vitae-I surely could use his help-which he surely would give to all of us with our "income problem" , unless he is a sociopath.

Reply

Leave a comment