Oswego Trustees Hear Presentation on Puppy Mills

The Puppy Mill Project is spreading the word about the dangers of pet stores and selling puppy mill pets.

If you own a dog, where did it come from? A breeder? Shelter? Or a pet store? 

If you answered yes to the latter, then you’re most likely supporting puppy mills, according to Jill Edelman, co-chair for the Puppy Mill Project.

What is the Village of Oswego going to do about it? That was the question at the Oswego Village Committee of the Whole meeting on Tuesday.

Want free local news in your inbox every morning? Sign up for our newsletter.

Presenters from the Puppy Mill Project are urging the village to pass an ordinance banning the resale of non-licensed and Unites States Department of Agriculture commercially bred puppies and kittens.

The Puppy Mill Project’s goal is to raise awareness about puppy mills and ultimately work with pet stores that already sell commercially bred puppies and have them adopt a humane business model.

“We have been very successful in this area,” said Edelman.

Edelman showed a Powerpoint presentation to village trustees of pictures of puppies in puppy mills crammed into small cages and described how they are forced to live outside no matter the weather. 

“The USDA requires that they have water, it doesn’t have to be clean water. They’re required to have food, but it doesn’t have to be nutritional. It could be sawdust mixed with animal fat,” said Edelman.

All of this, she said, is legal.

Further, most people don’t know that they are purchasing a puppy from a puppy mill when they go to a pet store, said Edelman.  

“They think they are getting puppies from respectable breeders. A respectable breeder would never sell to a pet store," she said.

Village President Brian LeClercq called the information was “a little disturbing” and asked, on a federal level, what exactly was being done to curb puppy mills.

Right now, Edelman said they first have to change the classification of puppies from livestock.

“There’s a lot of money being made on many levels. It’s a multi-billion dollar business we’re up against," she said.

The village recently approved a building permit for a pet store, Love Our Dogs, which would sell puppies.

Community Development Director Rod Zenner said that since they were issued their permit under the current ordinance that does not ban the retail sale of puppies or kittens they would be grandfathered in.

Local pet business owners also turned out to support the ordinance. Judy Haft from Central Bark in Oswego said many pet stories refuse to take a dog back after it's been purchased if there is a problem. However, 100 percent of the breeders she's known had accepted returned animals, she said.

“It’s a consumer issue. We need to ensure that the pet store will take the dog back and not put it in animal control on taxpayer dollars,” said Haft . “If that happens these stores will see the affect they have on the community.”

Edelman said the change to the ordinance was not meant to affect local, reputable breeders, but rather stop the sale of puppy mill puppies.

“Oswego has the chance to do the right thing," she said. 

When or if the village board will consider an ordinance banning the resale of non-licensed and Unites States Department of Agriculture commercially bred puppies and kittens is unclear.

For a slightly different take, follow us on Facebook.

Dolores Santucci November 02, 2012 at 01:36 AM
CORRECTION: Over 3 MILLION puppies are produced annually through puppy mills. Not 3000. Typo. My bad.
Susan F November 17, 2012 at 03:45 AM
Does anyone know if the Love our Dogs buys from puppy mills?
Judi Haft November 17, 2012 at 12:45 PM
Yes, Love our Dogs buys from puppy mills. That is the only way they can get puppies to be sold in that type of environment. AKC registered breeders will not sell in pet stores. A good breeder wants to know where their puppies are going and won't put their puppies in the hands of a 3rd party to decide that.
Donna Louise December 02, 2012 at 02:08 AM
To clarify, the AKC does sell AKC papers to puppy mill dogs/puppies. AKC papers are not an indication of health or breeding quality. But only puppy mill puppies are sold in pet stores or online. It's true that AKC registered Breeders (small private breeders) would never sell to a pet store.
Jodi January 30, 2013 at 08:48 PM
How do you know that is the case with this family? They have stated they used to live in southern MO and are close friends with the breeders from there. Without actually viewing where they get their dogs from it's a pretty harsh accusation. They offer pedigree information on the parents and I am sure you can get the breeder information from them. I'm just wondering if there are any cold hard facts about this place to back up that they get their puppies from puppy mills. We are looking for a puppy in the near future and I recently came across their website so I am just curious, not accusing anyone here.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »